Most pastors enter ministry knowing it will cost them something.
They sign up willingly to hold grief at hospital bedsides, to absorb anxiety during seasons of uncertainty, to carry conflict when values collide, and to remain present when a congregation is frightened, divided, or exhausted. Ministry is not a job so much as a vocation—one that asks for presence, compassion, and endurance.
What many church leaders do not fully see is how that cost accumulates, and what happens when the exchange goes unrecognized or unsupported.
The Hidden Exchange at the Heart of Ministry
Pastoral ministry involves a quiet and often invisible transfer—one that can be holy, life-giving, and deeply beautiful.
Week after week, pastors hold what a community cannot easily hold on its own:
-
Anxiety during uncertainty
-
Grief after loss
-
Conflict when values collide
-
Projection when fear looks for a target
-
Hope when the congregation feels depleted
None of this is inherently unhealthy. In fact, it is often part of what God uses to steady a people.
But over time, this holding becomes an accumulation. When there is no intentional release—no return to a deeper source—the weight settles not only in the mind, but in the body and the soul. Ministers begin to carry what was never meant to stay with them indefinitely.
Since 2020, this strain has become visible in national research as well. The Hartford Institute for Religion Research’s EPIC project reports that 53% of religious leaders surveyed in fall 2023 had seriously considered leaving pastoral ministry at least once since 2020, up from 37% in 2021. The same report found that 44% had seriously considered leaving their current congregation at least once since 2020, more than double the 21% reported in 2021.
These numbers represent something more than dissatisfaction. They reveal the cumulative toll of sustained emotional, spiritual, and relational demand—and the growing sense, for many clergy, that their inner resources are being spent faster than they can be replenished.
When Giving Exceeds Renewal
Here is where interreligious wisdom can be clarifying rather than distracting—because truth, when it is true, tends to echo.
In Daoist practice, we speak plainly about life energy—about what some call qi—and about the necessity of replenishment. When action exceeds alignment, vitality diminishes. When giving continues without return, the source itself becomes depleted. This is not moral failure. It is the honest physics of the human soul.
Translated into Christian language:
when ministry flows faster than communion with God, something essential is lost.
This is not about laziness or lack of devotion. It is about the reality that no human being can continually pour out without being filled.
During and after COVID, the demands on pastors intensified:
-
Constant crisis response
-
Polarized congregational dynamics
-
Rapid adaptation with little rest
-
Emotional availability without margin
Many pastors stayed in “active mode” far too long—out of love, responsibility, and faithfulness. For some, that season did not simply lead to fatigue; it led to deep injury. And many quietly left ministry altogether.
Scripture Knows This Pattern Well
The Christian tradition does not deny this reality. It names it.
Jesus repeatedly withdrew from the crowds—not because the need was gone, but because it was overwhelming. People wanted more healing, more teaching, more presence. And still, he left to be alone with God.
This was not avoidance. It was obedience.
Likewise, the prophet Elijah, after faithful and courageous service, collapses under the weight of his calling. God does not rebuke him. God feeds him, lets him sleep, and meets him not in spectacle or command, but in quiet presence. Only after restoration does direction return.
The message is consistent across Scripture:
faithful service without return to God leads to collapse.
Wounds That Accumulate, Not Weakness That Fails
When pastors leave ministry, it is rarely because they lacked faith or resilience. More often, it is because the wounds were never tended.
Burnout, unresolved conflict, and moral injury rarely arrive as sudden events. They form quietly—through months and years of absorbing what others cannot carry, while postponing one’s own healing.
Left unaddressed, these wounds can lead to:
-
Emotional numbness or reactivity
-
Boundary collapse or withdrawal
-
Loss of joy and clarity
-
Moral injury
-
Painful exits from vocations once deeply loved
This is not failure. It is what happens when healing is postponed too long.
Church boards and volunteer leaders need to understand this not as a staffing issue, but as a spiritual and pastoral reality.
The Role of Church Leaders: Protection, Not Pressure
Volunteer leaders are not responsible for fixing their pastor. But they are responsible for the conditions in which ministry happens.
That responsibility becomes concrete through protective practices—simple agreements that say, we will not consume what we claim to value.
Here are a few places to begin:
-
Protect a true Sabbath rhythm. A day off that is not “available if needed,” not “just a quick call,” not quietly erased by emergencies that are not emergencies.
-
Clarify after-hours expectations. Establish boundaries around texts, emails, and “one more thing” requests—so the pastor’s nervous system can actually come down.
-
Build in predictable solitude and prayer. Not only “vacation days,” but recurring space for retreat, spiritual direction, or a half-day of quiet that is treated as real work.
-
Create a conflict pathway that does not funnel everything to the pastor. When the pastor becomes the sole container for congregational anxiety, harm is almost inevitable.
-
Normalize rest before crisis forces it. Encourage renewal rhythms early—before burnout becomes the only language left.
-
Review role clarity annually. “What are we asking of you?” and “What have we added without noticing?” can be holy questions.
Self-care is not indulgence.
It is stewardship.
And solitude is not abandonment of ministry.
It is where ministry is restored.
Healing Comes from the Great Healer
Ultimately, no policy or practice can replace what pastors most need: regular return to God.
In silence.
In solitude.
In prayer that does not produce content, decisions, or outcomes.
This is where wounds are named.
This is where the soul is re-knit.
This is where the voice is heard again:
You are loved. You do not have to save everyone.
When this return is neglected, ministry itself can become destructive—consuming not only the role, but the person.
A Shared Responsibility
This is a word for pastors and for those who serve alongside them.
For pastors: your calling does not require self-destruction.
For church leaders: your pastor’s health is not peripheral to the mission—it is part of it.
Faithful ministry is sustained not by endless output,
but by continual return.
So here is a gentle question for a board, a council, a session, a leadership team:
What would it look like for our church to become a safer home for the people we ask to shepherd us?
Knowing this is not enough.
We have to become what we say we value—together.
Footnote: Hartford Institute for Religion Research, Exploring the Pandemic Impact on Congregations (EPIC) — “I’m Exhausted All the Time: Exploring the Factors Contributing to Growing Clergy Discontentment” (survey of ~1,700 religious leaders, fall 2023), via covidreligionresearch.org.
#DiscerningLeader #ChurchTrainingCenter #KeithClarkHoyos #PastoralCare #ClergyWellbeing #ChurchLeadership #HealthyMinistry #SpiritualFormation #Sabbath #Solitude #Prayer #BurnoutPrevention #MoralInjury #CongregationalHealth #InterreligiousDialogue #DaoistWisdom #ChristianLeadership #DiscerningLeaderBlog